I had first met Sarah at the FO Music Fest. She’s a working-class single mom from Ohio. Dreaming of scoring big, she traveled all the way from Los Angeles to Hong Kong for the festival. Not as a musician, of course, but as a FoAngel. She told me, eyes shining with hope, that winning the catwalk show could change her life, give her a platform, a future in this new Web3 world. As I watched her practice her walk, a nagging question kept swirling in my mind: Is this empowerment, or just another exploitation of dreams in a shiny, tech-fueled package?

Genuine Community Or Marketing Ploy?

The FO Music Fest, organized by Hengfeng International, wanted to bring a billion users to Web3. That's a bold, almost audacious goal. The Bamboo Park in West Kowloon was alive with possibilities. Those flashing lights and sounds signaled the dawning of an incredibly exciting digital age transformation. Qian Fenglei, Chairman of Hengfeng International, envisions a dynamic future powered by FO.COM. In this idealistic frontier, technology is music’s best friend, fosters organic digital-first communities, and bridges Web3 with the physical world’s economy. That all sounded amazing, a harmonic convergence of cutting-edge creativity and open-door acceptance.

Let's be real. Music festivals, no matter how much they’re dressed up in the cloak of Web3, are a natural extension of marketing. Here’s where marketing comes into play… Marketing is, for sure, the other piece of this puzzle! The only real question is whether the community aspect is genuine or simply an artifice crafted to sell the FO ecosystem.

I saw some genuine connections being made. Individuals from diverse communities, brought together by a common passion for Web3, sharing insights and forming connections. I saw many people who were just in it for the networking and self-promotion. They appeared to care much less about creating a real community. Were they really meeting people, or merely accumulating business cards? That’s a hard question, and the answer is probably in the shades of grey.

Inclusivity A Buzzword Or Reality?

The FO Music Fest billed itself as being open, inclusive, and diverse. How diverse was it, really? Were these marginalized groups equally represented, not only in the audience, but the speakers, performers, and individuals making programming decisions? Prepared as I was — I hadn’t expected to be surprised to see so many familiar faces, the usual suspects in the tech world.

In the back of my head though, I couldn’t stop thinking about the FoAngel Catwalk Show. Beyond a cash prize, the winner earns the opportunity to become an influencer for the rapidly growing brand. It’s a modern-day Cinderella story, digital edition. Cumulatively, this sounds incredible, but what kind of message does this send? And does it really democratize access? Or does it simply further entrench the notion that achievement is all about how you look and if you fit a brand’s look book? What about all of those women who don’t win? Are their dreams really crushed, another victim of the hype train?

That’s definitely reminiscent to me of the early days of reality TV. Delivering promises of fame and fortune, while more often than not, behind them lay a graveyard of broken dreams and exploited aspirations. Web3 shouldn't repeat those mistakes.

Million Dollar Prize: Empowerment or Exploitation?

The FO Million Dollar Prize Pool activity has an astounding 46,000+ participants. In many ways, this event reflects the thrilling potential for newfound wealth across the Web3 universe. The appeal of easy, fast cash is as tempting as it is obvious in a country that continues to face rampant economic insecurity.

Think about it. A million dollars. That’s life-changing money for most people. What are the odds of winning? More importantly, what are the costs? Participants are more or less making a deposit of their time, energy, and their own personal data into the FO ecosystem. Is the potential reward worth the risk?

This sure sounds like the California Gold Rush to me. Thousands poured into California, tempted by the possibility of getting rich overnight. A handful became instantly wealthy, but the overwhelming majority encountered only adversity and despair. Web3 just happens to be the latest new gold rush prospect. We need to be careful not to err all over again in the way we’ve done before.

Beyond The Hype Real-World Impact?

FO.COM believes that it’s only a matter of time before Web3 technologies reshape the world we live in today. These innovations will fundamentally change how we socialize, consume media, and transact. Their FoChat and FoPay platforms are integral pieces to this vision.

For one, they cry out for rigorous pilot and evaluation studies so that we can understand their real-world impact. Are they really doing good things for people and communities, or are they just reproducing and amplifying inequalities and exploitation in new ways? Are they solving real pain points, or just developing solutions looking for a problem?

We can’t just take this for granted in the face of hype. We have to see the real benefits (or detrimental effects) of the FO ecosystem. As a result, these exciting technologies are only available to those who can develop the expertise or afford the money to build them. Are they indeed achieving greater financial inclusion, or are they widening the inequalities that already exist? Which seems more empowering to users, allowing users to geo-fence their kids’ school or taking children’s location data and selling it to the highest bidder?

The short answer, I would submit, is layered and complicated. When used to their full potential, Web3 technologies can help communities take back their power. They need to be built and executed with inclusivity, transparency, and accountability first and foremost.

Sarah didn't win the catwalk. She was crushed. As I watched her pack her bags, I realized the FO Music Fest, like so many Web3 events, is a mixed bag. It’s all a mix of real innovation and hype, of community empowerment and risk of exploitation. Now it’s on us, the users, to hold these tools accountable and to call for more transparency, accountability, and inclusivity from the developers behind them. We need to be web3 smart shillers, not naive dreamers consuming the Web3 snake-oil sales pitch.

FeaturePotential BenefitPotential Pitfall
FoChatEnhanced social interaction, new communitiesPrivacy concerns, data exploitation
FoPaySeamless payments, financial inclusionSecurity risks, centralized control
FoAngel ShowPlatform for aspiring influencers, brand visibilityExploitation of dreams, unrealistic expectations
Prize PoolFinancial opportunity, user engagementUnrealistic odds, promotion of gambling behaviors

So too does the future of our digital communities. We have to make sure this new dawn doesn’t just work on the margins for the connected few, but actually benefits everybody sky’s the limit style.

The future of digital communities depends on it. We must ensure that the new dawn doesn't just benefit a select few, but truly empowers everyone.